I wanted to write about the female nude in art. From the beginning to the present day. What is it about the female nude that makes this a perennial and inexhaustible subject? Some paintings of the female nude can be erotic whilst others can be merely suggestive ie Matisse. His nudes are mere cutout silhouettes. I felt the subject was too broad until I managed to get a handle on it. The female nude is the visual representation of sexuality. If not sexual in nature then there is no point to the female being shown nude. Others might argue that form is the primary concern, yada yada yada. Yes, form is an element but ultimately we could find more challenges in the form of a muscular male body.
Other nudes such as those of Ingres are sensuous because the skin tone is tangible to the viewer.
Michelangelo painted female nudes (see Sistine Chapel) that look like muscular men with tacked on breasts. The intention here is purely narrative. Yet other nudes that illustrate biblical stories or mythological episodes are clearly erotic in intent. The Birth of Venus by Botticelli seems to us today to be interesting but erotic? I'm not sure. Maybe in his time it would have constituted the pinnacle of erotic art.
The visual representation of the female nude conjures up erotic feelings simply because the female is undressed.
The nude female in art is invariably young and attractive. There is no desire to look at a geriatric nude, bent double, arthritic and wrinkled.Of course there are always exceptions, see Lucian Freud.
This in itself explains the need to portray a female without clothes.It is to admire, to appreciate, to celebrate the beauty of the human figure.
In the triptych The Garden of Earthly Delights, by Hieronymous Bosch the nude figure is used to portray sin. Sin and sexuality seems to go hand in hand. Thanks to religion of course.
So we discover that explicit sexuality seems to be missing in western art except for the pre-Christian era. Look at the paintings from Pompei for example. The female nude is always used to imply sexuality. Even in paintings such as
The Rape of the Sabines, a popular subject amongst artists, Rubens' interpretation is more explicit in nudity but the theme is more concerned with movement and composition than explicit sexuality. There is naked female bodies, groping and struggle. The rest is left to the imagination.
It seems that if any erotic art did exist, it might have been destroyed by Christian zealots. In contrast, there is much to see in Indian and Japanese art. Other non-Christian cultures didn't seem to have a problem with sexually explicit (erotic) art. It appears to be a Christian/Western characteristic that we are obsessed with distinguishing between what is deemed pornography and art.
Another interesting aspect of the portrayal of the female nude is that not until Lucian Freud do we see a body that is less than ideal.
It's here that we come to a critical point of observation. Is Freud concerned with sexuality or merely breaking through the frontiers of convention? Maybe some viewers might find his nude figures of obese women erotic. I think it goes further that just an exercise in titillation.
To be continued...
Wednesday, November 19, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Labels
- 1929 Wall Street Crash (1)
- 4th July (1)
- 7 July 2005 London bombings (1)
- 9/11 (1)
- A.Q.Khan (1)
- Abdel Kareem Nabil Suleiman (1)
- aboriginal (1)
- Aboriginal history (1)
- Aborigines (8)
- Abstract art (1)
- abstract painting (1)
- Abu Bakar Bashir (1)
- Abu Ghraib prison (1)
- actors and politics (1)
- Advertising (1)
- AFDI (1)
- affluence (1)
- Afghanistan (2)
- Africa (1)
- African politics (1)
- Agriculture (1)
- Ahmadinejad (1)
- Ahmed Elomar (1)
- Aid (1)
- Al Qaida (1)
- Alain (1)
- Alain de Botton (1)
- Alcoholism (1)
- Aluminum Corporation of China Limited (1)
- Andrew Sullivan (1)
- Android (3)
- Andy Warhol (1)
- anti rape (1)
- anti-Americanism (1)
- Anxiety (1)
- APEC (2)
- Apps (1)
- Art (20)
- Ash Wednesday fires (1)
- asylum seeker (3)
- Atheism (1)
- Atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki (1)
- Attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (1)
- Australia (31)
- Australia 1955 (1)
- Australia Day (3)
- Australian art (1)
- Australian Defence Force (1)
- Australian flood and drought (2)
- Australian immigration (1)
- Australian saints (1)
- Australiana (1)
- Australians (2)
- auto-biography (2)
- AWB (1)
- Ayaan Hirsi Ali (1)
- Ayatollah Khomeni (1)
- bad manners (1)
- bad news (2)
- Bailout (1)
- Bali (1)
- Barack Obama (1)
- Batman (1)
- Batman movie review (1)
- Beauty (7)
- Behaviour (1)
- behaviour and algorithm (1)
- beheadings (1)
- Belgium (1)
- Bertrand Russell (1)
- BHP Billiton (1)
- bi-polar (1)
- Big Beautiful Woman (1)
- big women (2)
- Billy Connolly (1)
- biography (2)
- biological warfare (1)
- Bipolar disorder (1)
- birthday (1)
- bittorrent (1)
- Black Dahlia (1)
- blog stats (1)
- bloggers (2)
- blogging (3)
- Blogging for health (1)
- Blu (1)
- boat people (2)
- Body building babes (1)
- Body image (1)
- Body piercing (1)
- Bolivian Highway (1)
- book review (1)
- books and movies (2)
- Borderline personality disorder (1)
- Boston (1)
- Botanical gardens (1)
- Bottle water (1)
- Bottlenose dolphin (1)
- Boy Scouts (1)
- breastfeeding (1)
- breasts (1)
- Brett Whiteley (1)
- Brett Whitely (1)
- Brigitte (1)
- British National (1)
- brothel (2)
- bucket meme (1)
- bureaucracy (1)
- Bureaucrats (2)
- Burkah (4)
- burqa (1)
- burqah (3)
- Bushfire (2)
- Bushfires (8)
- Buttersnatch (1)
- Cacti and Succulents (1)
- Cactus (1)
- CAIR (2)
- Canadian Human Rights Commission (1)
- Candida (2)
- Candida Albican (1)
- Candida Albicans (1)
- Candidiasis (1)
- Capital punishment and Sharia Law (1)
- Capitalism (1)
- Carbon credit (1)
- Carbon Credits (1)
- Carbon dioxide (1)
- carbon tax (2)
- Carbon trading scheme (1)
- cartoons (2)
- Catholic Church (3)
- Catholic priest (2)
- Cats (5)
- celebrities (1)
- Celebrity and fame (1)
- celebrity cult (1)
- celibacy (1)
- celibacy and religion (1)
- censorship (3)
- characters (1)
- Charles Darwin (1)
- Charlie Hebdo (1)
- chauvinism (1)
- child abuse (4)
- Child crime (2)
- China (2)
- chocolate cake (1)
- Chris Lane (1)
- Christian nudists (1)
- Christiansex (1)
- Christine Nixon (1)
- Christmas (15)
- Christmas day (1)
- Christmas gift ideas (1)
- Christopher Caldwell (1)
- civilization (1)
- climate change (15)
- Climate science (1)
- Coincidence (1)
- colloquialisms (1)
- comedy (1)
- Comminsure (1)
- community (1)
- computer art (1)
- Conduct Disorder (1)
- cons (1)
- Consolations of Philosophy (1)
- conspiracy theory (1)
- consumerism (1)
- Contermporary Art (1)
- Convert to Islam (2)
- copenhage summit (1)
- copyright (1)
- Corporal punishment (1)
- Corporate Pop music (1)
- Corruption (1)
- Cosmology (1)
- cost cutting (1)
- Crime (1)
- crime does pay (1)
- Criminal justice (1)
- criminals (2)
- criticizing Islam (1)
- Cultue wars (1)
- Cultural aggression (1)
- Culturalism (11)
- culture (10)
- Culture war (1)
- culture wars.culturism (1)
- culturism (14)
- Dalai Lama (1)
- Dali (1)
- Dambisa Moyo (1)
- danger (1)
- Danish cartoons (1)
- Danny Nalliah (1)
- Dark Knight (1)
- David Hicks (2)
- Dead Aid: Why Aid Is Not Working and How There Is a Better Way for Africa (1)
- Deadwood (1)
- Death (1)
- Decline of the West (1)
- Defense policy (1)
- Dementia (1)
- Democracy (3)
- Depression (2)
- Design (1)
- Desire (1)
- Dhimmi (1)
- Dictators (1)
- Diet (1)
- digital art (1)
- Discrimination (1)
- Disorders (1)
- disturbed (1)
- diverticulitis (1)
- dogs (1)
- Domestic violence (1)
- Domino theory (1)
- Donald Horne (1)
- Donald Rumsfeld (1)
- doppelgänger (1)
- Doug Harrington (1)
- Dr Elizabeth Blackburn (1)
- Dr Tim Flannery (2)
- Dreams and the subconscious (1)
- drinking water (2)
- Drive by shooting (1)
- drought (4)
- Drowning (1)
- drugs (1)
- Dwarf (1)
- Easter (2)
- Eclipse of the moon (1)
- economic meltdown (1)
- Economic policy (1)
- economic refugees (1)
- Economics (10)
- economy (1)
- EDL (1)
- Education (6)
- efficiency (1)
- Egypt (3)
- Election strategy (1)
- Election violence (1)
- electric cars (1)
- electricity (1)
- Elisabeth Sabaditsch-Wolff (1)
- Emissions trading (2)
- English (1)
- English education (1)
- English language (1)
- Ennio Morricone (1)
- environment (5)
- epilepsy (1)
- Erotica (1)
- eroticism (1)
- Ethics (1)
- ETS (1)
- Europe and Islam (2)
- Euthanasia (3)
- EV (1)
- Evil (2)
- Evolution (5)
- Evolution and abortion (1)
- Evolution meme (1)
- exotic plants (1)
- Extremists (1)
- Facebook (1)
- Faith (2)
- fanatics (1)
- Far North Queensland (1)
- Fashion (9)
- fashion police (1)
- fat. (1)
- Father Christmas (1)
- Favorite books (1)
- Fear (1)
- February 2009 Victorian bushfires (1)
- Feminism (1)
- fidelity (1)
- finance (1)
- Firefox (1)
- Firefox and MS Media Player (1)
- Fistful of Dollars (1)
- Fitna (1)
- flickr (1)
- flood (2)
- Floods (4)
- flowers (1)
- Food (1)
- food allergy food intolerance (1)
- Football (1)
- Foreign policy (1)
- Fort Hood (1)
- Fractal art (1)
- fractals (2)
- Fred Hollows (1)
- free market (1)
- Freedom of Religion (1)
- Freedom of Speech (5)
- Full moon (1)
- Funny news (1)
- funny pix (1)
- G20 (1)
- Gaddafi (1)
- Galileo Galilei (1)
- Gangland news (1)
- Garage sales (1)
- Garden gnomes (1)
- Gardening (2)
- Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras (1)
- gay muslims (1)
- gays (1)
- Geert Wilders (3)
- Genetic engineering (4)
- Genetically modified food (1)
- gentic engineering (1)
- Georgia (1)
- Germain Greer (1)
- Girlfriend Experience (1)
- Global Financial Crisis (1)
- Global warming (3)
- globalisation (1)
- Globalization (1)
- GM crops (1)
- Goat (1)
- God (5)
- gold-diggers (1)
- good versus evil (1)
- Google (3)
- googleartproject (1)
- government (2)
- Great Apes (1)
- Greed (1)
- Greek Easter (2)
- greenhouse (1)
- Greenhouse gas (2)
- greenouse effect (1)
- Grevillea robusta (1)
- Gripes of Wrath (1)
- Ground Zero Mosque (2)
- guilt by association (1)
- Gun control (1)
- Guns (2)
- guns and children (1)
- gypsies (1)
- Hamas (3)
- happiness (1)
- Happy University (1)
- Hard Rain's A Gonna Fall (1)
- Hardline Muslim clerics (1)
- Harry Seidler (1)
- Hate Speech (3)
- Head (1)
- headscarves (1)
- health (7)
- health and evolution (1)
- Health care (1)
- HealthInsurance (1)
- Hearts and Minds of Muslims (1)
- Hijab (2)
- Hizb ut-Tahir (1)
- Hizb ut-Tahrir (1)
- Ho Hum (2)
- Holocaust memorial day (1)
- honor killings (1)
- How Proust Can Change Your Life (1)
- How to spot a terrorist (1)
- Howard Florey (1)
- Hugh Hefner (1)
- Hugh Laurie (1)
- Human brain (1)
- Human Growth Hormone (1)
- Human rights (3)
- Human Rights and Islam (1)
- Human Rights Commission (1)
- humor (74)
- humour (42)
- Ice Cream Sandwich (1)
- ideology (2)
- illegal immigrants (1)
- Illegal immigration (3)
- Images of Mahommed (1)
- Imagine this (1)
- Immigration (1)
- immortality (1)
- In Cold Blood (1)
- Index finger (1)
- Indians and culture (1)
- Indigenous (3)
- indoctrination (1)
- Indonesia (2)
- Influenza pandemic (1)
- information (1)
- Inglourious Basterds (1)
- insanity (2)
- Insurance (1)
- intelligent design (1)
- interest rates (1)
- International student (1)
- International Women's Day (1)
- Internet email scams (1)
- Internet scams (1)
- iPad (1)
- iPhone competition scam (1)
- IQ (1)
- IQ and Muslims (1)
- Iran (3)
- Iraq (1)
- ISIS (3)
- ISIS in Australia (1)
- Islam (104)
- Islam and incest (1)
- Islam and Jesus (1)
- Islam in Australia (1)
- Islamic hygiene (1)
- Islamic State (1)
- Islamification Europe (1)
- Islamism (1)
- Islamist dickhead (1)
- Islamists (4)
- Israel (1)
- Italy (1)
- IVF (1)
- James Foley (1)
- Japanese Whale Hunting (research) (1)
- Japanese whale research (1)
- JC Hutchins (1)
- Jehovah's Witnesses (1)
- Jihad (5)
- Jihad and Islam (1)
- Jihad and WMD (1)
- John Galliano (1)
- John Maynard Keynes (1)
- John Olsen (1)
- Joker (1)
- jokes (1)
- Jon Ronson (1)
- Julian Assange (2)
- Justice (2)
- Justice Michael Kirby (1)
- K (1)
- Karadzic (1)
- Karma group (1)
- keffiyeh (1)
- Keiko Matsui (1)
- Keith Floyd (1)
- Kenya (1)
- Khalid's confession (1)
- kleptocracy (1)
- Koalas (1)
- Kramer (1)
- Kveta (1)
- La Primitiva (1)
- Lady Gaga (1)
- language (4)
- Lauren Bentley (1)
- Law (1)
- League of Nations (1)
- Lexcen on Economic policy (1)
- Lexx (2)
- Life expectancy (1)
- Life Insurance (1)
- Life of Pi (1)
- Literature (1)
- LittleBigPlanet (1)
- Lucian Freud (1)
- Made in China (1)
- Major depressive disorder (1)
- Management (1)
- Manus Island (1)
- marijuana (1)
- Marketing and Advertising (1)
- Marketing strategy (1)
- Marxism (1)
- Marysville (1)
- Max Ernst (1)
- McMafia: A Journey Through the Global Criminal Underworld (1)
- Meaningful Outcomes (1)
- media (1)
- Media hype (1)
- media spin (1)
- Medicare (1)
- Medicine (2)
- Melbourn comedy festival (1)
- Melbourne International Film Festival (1)
- Melbourne Robert de Niro (1)
- Melbourne summer (3)
- Meltdown (1)
- Meme (4)
- memes (1)
- Men's fashion (1)
- men's handbags (1)
- Mental Health (2)
- Michael Crichton (1)
- Michael Jackson (1)
- MIddle East (1)
- Military strategy (1)
- Minarets (1)
- Mind of the Musulman (1)
- mini pigs. (1)
- Minorities and multiculturalism (1)
- Miss World (1)
- mistaken identity (1)
- Mobile home (1)
- Moderate Islam (1)
- moles (1)
- Monsanto (1)
- Monty Python (1)
- morality and war (1)
- Morsi (1)
- Mothers' Day (1)
- movie review (3)
- Movies (5)
- Multi -culturism and Islam (1)
- multi-culturalism (4)
- multi-culturism (3)
- multiculturalism (4)
- Museum (1)
- music (3)
- Musings (1)
- Muslim (70)
- Muslim atrocities (1)
- Muslim Brotherhood (4)
- Muslim discrimination (1)
- Muslim extremism (1)
- Muslim Hip Hop (1)
- Muslim humor (1)
- Muslim immigration (1)
- Muslim integration (1)
- Muslim propaganda (1)
- Muslim reformists speak (1)
- Muslim schools (1)
- muslims (38)
- Muslims in government (1)
- Myotherapy (1)
- Myth of Mental Illness (1)
- Nagasaki (1)
- Naked (1)
- naked art (1)
- naked bike riding (1)
- Naked protest (1)
- native title (1)
- neighbors (2)
- Neo Nazis (1)
- New breasts (1)
- New Year (1)
- news (1)
- Niall Ferguson (1)
- nipples (1)
- Niqab (3)
- No comment (1)
- Noah's ark (1)
- Nobel Peace Prize (1)
- Norman Lindsay (1)
- North Korea (1)
- Nuclear (1)
- nuclear power (2)
- Nuclear weapons (1)
- nudity (1)
- numbers (1)
- Obesity (2)
- obsessions (1)
- Odyssey (1)
- offensive (1)
- Oil (3)
- Olympics (2)
- Once Upon a Time in the West (1)
- Online shopping (1)
- only about me (1)
- Opinion Poll (2)
- Oppositional Defiant Disorder (1)
- oral sex (1)
- orchids (1)
- orgasm (1)
- Oscar Pistorius (1)
- Outcome-based education (1)
- Outcomes Based Education (1)
- Paint (1)
- Painting (2)
- Palliative care (1)
- Panama Papers (1)
- Pandemic (2)
- Papal fashions (1)
- Paradigms (1)
- paranoia (3)
- Pat Condell (6)
- Pauline Hanson (1)
- PC humor (1)
- peace loving Muslims (1)
- Peacekeeping (1)
- penis poll (1)
- people (2)
- people smugglers (1)
- perception blindness (1)
- perceptual blindness (1)
- personal (4)
- personality test (1)
- Peter Carey (1)
- Peter Singer (2)
- Petitions (1)
- pets (1)
- Philosophy (5)
- photography (9)
- photos (6)
- Picasa (1)
- Picasa 3 (1)
- Pin stripe nazis (1)
- piracy (1)
- pix (1)
- plastic surgery (1)
- poetry (2)
- points of view (1)
- political activism (1)
- political cartoon (1)
- Political correctness (4)
- politically incorrect (1)
- Politically incorrect censorship (1)
- politics (2)
- Politics of Sexuality (2)
- polygamy (1)
- Pompeii (1)
- pop singers (1)
- Pope Benedict XVI (1)
- Pope Pius XII (1)
- popups (1)
- porn (2)
- Porn addiction (1)
- Porn hysteria (1)
- pornography (1)
- Port Douglas (1)
- portrait (1)
- poverty (1)
- power failure (2)
- Priesthood (1)
- Prison (1)
- Privacy (1)
- privatisation (1)
- privatisation sucks (1)
- profile (1)
- prophesies of doom (1)
- Prostate (1)
- prostatitis (1)
- prostitution (2)
- protecting the children (1)
- Protectionism (1)
- psychology (1)
- psychopaths (2)
- public panic (1)
- Putin (1)
- Puzzle (1)
- Qu'ran (1)
- Quit Smoking (1)
- Racism (11)
- Racism? (1)
- radical Islam (1)
- rain (1)
- Ramadan (1)
- Rape (1)
- Reality television (1)
- Rebiya Kadeer (1)
- Recipes (4)
- Red Bubble (1)
- Refugee (2)
- Refugees (9)
- religion (27)
- religion and the mind (1)
- Religion of Peace (2)
- Rembrandt (1)
- Rio Tinto Group (1)
- Ritz-Carlton (1)
- Roberto Saviano (1)
- Robin Williams (1)
- Roman Catholic Church (1)
- Romanians (1)
- ROPMA (2)
- Royal Commission (1)
- Russia (3)
- Saddam Hussein (1)
- Saint John Paul II (1)
- salt (1)
- Salvador Dali (2)
- Sam Harris (1)
- Santa Claus (1)
- Satanic Verses (1)
- Saudi sponsored terrorism (1)
- Save the planet (1)
- Savings (1)
- sayings (1)
- Scams (1)
- science (4)
- science and religion (1)
- Science fiction (1)
- Scientific Research (1)
- Scientology (5)
- Scientology and religion (1)
- Screen Capture (1)
- Sealy mattress (1)
- Serbs (1)
- Sergio Leone (1)
- Sex education (1)
- Sex survey (1)
- Sex Work (1)
- Sex worker (1)
- Sexual harassment (1)
- sexuality (1)
- sexuality in art (1)
- Shakespeare (1)
- Sharia Law (3)
- ShariaLaw in UK.culturism (1)
- Sheik Omran (1)
- shower (1)
- shroud of Turin (1)
- Simon and Garfunkel (1)
- Single Malt Scotch (1)
- Sir Mark Oliphant (1)
- Skeptical Inquiry (1)
- skinny dip (1)
- Sneezing (1)
- Society and Culture (3)
- Solomon Trujillo (1)
- Sony (1)
- Spaghetti Western (1)
- SPAM (1)
- speed cameras (1)
- Spirituality (1)
- Sport (3)
- Srebrenica (1)
- Starvation (1)
- Status Anxiety (1)
- Stephen Fry (1)
- Stephen Hawking (1)
- stoning (1)
- storm damage and floods (1)
- stupidity (1)
- Style (2)
- Subprime lending (1)
- sugar (1)
- suicide bombers (1)
- summer snow (1)
- Superstition (1)
- Surfing (1)
- Surrealism (2)
- Survival (1)
- Svante Arrhenius (1)
- Swine influenza (5)
- Symbolism (1)
- Syria (1)
- Tagged (2)
- Taliban (1)
- talking cats (1)
- Tariq Modood (1)
- Tariq Ramadan (1)
- tax (1)
- taxes (1)
- tech stuff (1)
- Technorati (1)
- TED (1)
- Telstra (1)
- terrorism (16)
- Terrorist doctors (1)
- Terrorist funding (1)
- Terrorist organizations (1)
- Terry Jones (1)
- Thanksgiving (1)
- the arts (1)
- The Bible Unearthed (1)
- The Borg (1)
- the Caliphate (1)
- The Constant Gardener: A Novel (1)
- The Dickhead award (1)
- The Good the Bad and the Ugly (1)
- The internet and misinformation (1)
- The Lucifer Principle: A Scientific Expedition into the Forces of History (1)
- The Odessa conspiracy (1)
- the Pope (1)
- The rich (1)
- the universe (1)
- Theeconomic meltdown (1)
- theinvisible hand (1)
- Theo Van Gogh (1)
- Theology (1)
- thieves (1)
- Thinking Blogger Award (1)
- Thomas Szasz (1)
- Tiger Woods (1)
- Tim Winton (1)
- Time machines (1)
- Time travel (2)
- tinkering (1)
- Titanic (1)
- tits (1)
- Tolerance (1)
- Tolerating Muslims (1)
- Tolstoy (1)
- Tom Tom (1)
- too much money syndrome (1)
- Torture (3)
- Travel (1)
- Tribal Law (1)
- Trojan horses (1)
- Truman Capote (1)
- Truth (2)
- Twitter (1)
- Ulysse Nardin (1)
- UN security council (1)
- United Nations (1)
- United States (1)
- US illegal immigrants (1)
- Vacation (1)
- vaginas (1)
- vaginoplasty (1)
- value (1)
- value of opinions (1)
- Vatican (1)
- Victoria (2)
- Video game (1)
- videos (1)
- Viet Cong (1)
- Violence (2)
- Violence and Muslims (1)
- violence ethnics (1)
- Vista administrator bypass (1)
- Visual Arts (3)
- Vladimir Putin (1)
- Wahabism (1)
- War and Peace (1)
- War Crimes (1)
- War on Drugs (1)
- War on Terror (1)
- Warning (1)
- Warrior Citizen (1)
- Water (2)
- Wealth (1)
- Weapons of Mass Destruction (1)
- Weird News (1)
- welfare (1)
- Western culture (1)
- What is Faith? (1)
- Wikileaks (2)
- windows live (1)
- Wisdom (1)
- Wollemi pine (1)
- Woody Allen (1)
- world oil reserves (1)
- WTF (1)
- Yann Martel (1)
- Yasser Arafat (1)
- You Tube (1)
- Yusuf al-Qaradawi (1)
- Zimbabwe (1)
23 comments:
I've been pondering this post since you put it up. There's just so much there. When it comes down to it, commonplace, art and porn may be in the eye of the beholder.
I think it all depends on the mindset of the viewer which may be heavily influenced by their sex and orientation. For one, nudity may detract from the artistry while for another it enhances.
When I see Asian or Kama Sutra types of sexual drawings, I think of it more as educational art than pornographic art.
And what is really the difference between erotica and pornography?
Maybe judging the intent of both the artist and the viewer are necessary to make the distinctions - it's not a matter of whether a particular work is or is not based on it's own merit. Fashion and sensibilities change. Victorians put pantaloons on piano legs so young men wouldn't get aroused. They were excited by a "well-turned" ankle. What about fundamentalist Muslims? Are they more aroused by the modesty of the burka or the exhibitionism of the western whore?
Love American Style had a skit once where a man had a date with a porn actress who always wore gloves and never let anyone see her hands naked. His friend couldn't wait to hear about his friend's exploits, expecting wild abandoned sex. At the end of the evening, he finally asks his buddy who says wistfully - "I got to hold her hand"
Is Freud concerned with sexuality or merely breaking through the frontiers of convention? Maybe some viewers might find his nude figures of obese women erotic. I think it goes further that just an exercise in titillation.
So, we can agree on something again. In the words of Emerson, " In the true mythology, Love is an immortal child, and Beauty leads him as a guide: nor can we express a deeper sense than when we say, Beauty is the pilot of the young soul,"; but the 'Good' must be pursued with at least three sometimes incommensurable "ideas", and not merely the childish/oftern brutish guide of "love/desire" alone. One also requires a more manly courage, fortitude and judgement necessary to "stare into the abyss" so as to discern the truth inherent in the eternal nature of life and the universe and "listen" to his own voice of reason.
Some of the "sins" in Freud's subject are obvious through their manifestion in the subject's "appearance". Whereas those of Boticelli's Venus may be masked by an "appearance" of beauty and therefore much more difficult for judgement to discern.
We are all private charioteers, not merely individual horses. Plato, "Phaedrus"
The followers of Ares are fierce and violent; those of Zeus seek out some philosophical and imperial nature; the attendants of Here find a royal love; and in like manner the followers of every god seek a love who is like their god; and to him they communicate the nature which they have received from their god. The manner in which they take their love is as follows:—
I told you about the charioteer and his two steeds, the one a noble animal who is guided by word and admonition only, the other an ill-looking villain who will hardly yield to blow or spur. Together all three, who are a figure of the soul, approach the vision of love. And now a fierce conflict begins. The ill-conditioned steed rushes on to enjoy, but the charioteer, who beholds the beloved with awe, falls back in adoration, and forces both the steeds on their haunches; again the evil steed rushes forwards and pulls shamelessly. The conflict grows more and more severe; and at last the charioteer, throwing himself backwards, forces the bit out of the clenched teeth of the brute, and pulling harder than ever at the reins, covers his tongue and jaws with blood, and forces him to rest his legs and haunches with pain upon the ground. When this has happened several times, the villain is tamed and humbled, and from that time forward the soul of the lover follows the beloved in modesty and holy fear. And now their bliss is consummated; the same image of love dwells in the breast of either, and if they have self-control, they pass their lives in the greatest happiness which is attainable by man—they continue masters of themselves, and conquer in one of the three heavenly victories. But if they choose the lower life of ambition they may still have a happy destiny, though inferior, because they have not the approval of the whole soul. At last they leave the body and proceed on their pilgrim's progress, and those who have once begun can never go back. When the time comes they receive their wings and fly away, and the lovers have the same wings.
It's not surprising then that so few charioteers are "statesmenlike" enough to ever go on to master the quadriga.
Jeannie, your comment is much appreciated.
FJ, sorry to say I missed the sub-conscious connection between Lucian Freud and Sigmund Freud. I should know better. Of course Freud and sexuality go hand in hand like peaches and cream. Was it my Freudian slip?
I was speaking of Lucian, myself, although on first read I thought perhaps you were talking about Sigmund... so likely it's my own slip that's showing.
As for Bosch's painting, I think you need to cut him some slack. As the first 'surrealist', I'm sure that his sins of the "flesh" were born of Platonic silver-gold dialectic and mind-body dualism.
Alice, mind/body dualism? Yes, maybe that's where Christianity gets its dislike of sexuality. But to think of Bosch as a surrealist? He would be offended. His visions are very much real to him. Bosch is a moralist. Maybe he read too much of the Divine Comedy.
His visions were real to him? How surreal! All Dali did was paint what he thought was behind what Sigmund Freud saw.
FJ, I could say a lot about surrealism but this quote from wikipedia seems to sum it up,
: Surrealism, n. Pure psychic automatism, by which one proposes to express, either verbally, in writing, or by any other manner, the real functioning of thought. Dictation of thought in the absence of all control exercised by reason, outside of all aesthetic and moral preoccupation.
It's a bad definition.
Automatism is merely one school of surrealism... the school subsribed to by the untalented commies that hated Dali's success.
Look at Dali's Gradiva's. If that's not Sigmund Freud, then nothing is. Take it from someone who has taken the time to actually READ Freud.
Here's an abstract on Freud's "Gradiva".
Dali's painting are x1,000 more interesting that the fake-authenticity inherent in the Frida Khalo cult.
btw- If you ever need described the process by which the "real functioning of thought" occurs, just ask. I've got the real answer to that one down pat. ;-)
You could use it (to confuse?) both "consciousness" AND "vision".
Interesting as the article on Gradiva might be, I still think it's tenuous connection between Dali and Freud. Dali was full of psychological issues, ie his dead twin brother. Dali was also sexually inadequate. No wonder he would have had an interest in Freud. The Great Masturbator sums up Dali. Coupled with the anecdotal story of how he masturbated himself in front of an unwary woman (Dali's personal version of sex) and you have the makings of a very interesting case study for Sigmund Freud. Look at Dali's paintings of melting clocks, impotence yells out at you. It's also interesting that Dali never painted anything erotic. Picasso was more comfortable with his own sexuality for example and he did many drawings and sketches of vaginas.
I don't have much regard for Frida Khalo. Maybe she's an icon for feminists?
Commies. One of Trotsky's hotsky's.
Tenuous? LOL!
Sorry, but Dali's reputation was savaged by his jealous commie rivals. You should spend more time examining his works and less reading bio's in Lefty-authored art books.
Unless of course, you're some sort of Marxist-Lenist, Hitler devotee or volunteer for the Abraham Lincoln Brigaid.
Dali never painted anything erotic? Gala was H-O-T!
FJ, my opinions on Dali are personal, how dare you accuse me of being a commie :-) My God, you are passionate about Dali. From a man's point of view I didn't find Gala erotic in the least. Botticelli's Venus is definitely more erotic. Even Caravaggio's youth's are more erotic. A naked Gala doesn't make her hot.
Yeah, but look at that staircase leading up to her! As Freud would interpret a staircase, open doors, and "chests" of drawers... Woo-hoo!
I know I'd love to get into her drawers.
Yep, the Commies sure love Frida. She's slated to be designated, "greatest artist of the 20th century".
Post a Comment